🇺🇸 United States · Hybrid (coils and foam) vs Hybrid (coils and foam)

Puffy DiamondvsAllswell Supreme

Which one is best for you? Puffy Diamond vs Allswell Supreme - 2026 comparison by Vs Mattress

Vs Mattress is reader-supported, that means if you buy something via a link on this page, we might earn a commission. Thank you kindly.

Puffy DiamondEnjoy $1,350 In SavingsAllswell Supreme

Top pick

Puffy Diamond

by Puffy · Hybrid (coils and foam)

Enjoy $1,350 In Savings

LIFETIME · 101-night trial

Allswell Supreme

by Allswell · Hybrid (coils and foam)

10 years · 100-night trial

Pricing by size

Puffy Diamond

Twinn/a

Twin XL$3,349

Full (Double)n/a

Queen$4,649

King$5,149

California King$5,149

Allswell Supreme

Twin$517

Twin XL$547

Full (Double)$597

Queen$687

King$797

California King$797

Essential information

	Puffy Diamond	Allswell Supreme
Type	Hybrid (coils and foam)	Hybrid (coils and foam)
Launched	2023	–
Brand	Puffy	Allswell
Made in	United States	United States
Unique points	The Puffy Diamond Hybrid is the new premium mattress featuring 10 layers: Cooling Quilted Cloud Cover Alpaca Wool Filling Climate Fiber Layer Full-Body Pressure-Relief Enhanced Cushioning Foam Diamond Latex Response Layer Reflexive Memory Foam Cloud Air Technology Foam Firm Core Support Foam + Contour-Adapt Coils Grip Base Cover	The Supreme mattress by Allswell is the best in their lineup, constructed of the following layers: Quilted Cover + Euro Top Graphite & Copper Gel Infused Memory Foam Energex Foam Quantum Edge Individually Wrapped Coils.
Video	Puffy Mattress - The Most Comfortable Mattress	–

Certifications & trial

	Puffy Diamond	Allswell Supreme
OEKO-TEX®	Yes	No
CertiPUR-US®	Yes	Yes
Certifications	CertiPur-US®, OEKO-TEX®	CertiPur-US®
Other certification info	–	<p id="">Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)USDA Organic GREENGUARD Gold Eco-INSTITUT MADE SAFE® Rainforest Alliance Certified™ Forest Stewardship Council®</p>
Sleep trial	101 nights	100 nights
Warranty	LIFETIME	10 years
Free shipping	–	–
Free returns	Yes	Yes
Pay later	Yes	Yes
Delivery info	The mattress comes shipped in box direct to your door typically within 2 to 5 business days via FedEx.	Allswell offers free ground shipping to the 48 contiguous US states & DC.

Firmness & feel

	Puffy Diamond	Allswell Supreme
One firmness fits all	Yes	Yes
Select your firmness	No	No
Adjustable firmness	No	No
Half and half firmness	No	No
Flippable / reversible	No	No
Firmness info	The mattress is described as "LUXURY-PLUSH" on the scale provided. Typically, in the mattress industry, a "luxury-plush" designation suggests a softer feel, but without the specific number, it's hard to pinpoint its exact position on a 1-10 firmness scale.	That just-right medium-firm feel. Rated a 4.5 to 6.5 on the very unscientific firmness scale.

Construction & materials

	Puffy Diamond	Allswell Supreme
Layers	Cooling Quilted Cloud Cover, Alpaca Wool Filling, Climate Fiber Layer, Full-Body Pressure-Relief, Enhanced Cushioning Foam, Diamond Latex Response Layer, Reflexive Memory Foam, Cloud Air Technology Foam, Firm Core Support Foam + Contour-Adapt Coils, Grip Base Cover	Quilted Cover + Euro Top, Graphite & Copper Gel Infused Memory Foam, Energex Foam, Quantum Edge Individually Wrapped Coils.
Cover	Its luxurious construction means that spot cleaning is recommended for the Puffy Diamond, while all other models feature a Stain-Resistant Cloud Cover that can be removed from the mattress and cleaned with mild detergents and household cleaners. The Puffy Signature Mattress Protector is free with every mattress purchase and is a wonderful addition that keeps your luxury purchase protected from stains, spills, wear and tear.	Quilted top panel woven with our signature A. This is a Euro top mattress with two layers of high-performance memory foam underneath its plush quilted surface which makes for a supreme sleep experience.
Machine-washable cover	No	No
Ergonomic handles	Yes	No
Comfort	Experience unparalleled sleep luxury with a unique blend of materials. Dive into the soft feel of alpaca wool paired with the airy comfort of latex, ensuring a perfect match for over a hundred risk-free nights. This luxury-plush mattress offers ultra-responsive support and targeted contouring for every part of your body. Enhanced cushioning and quilted layers provide optimal climate control, known for its softness and thermoregulation properties. This isn't just about comfort; it's about a legendary sleep experience. Embrace a sleep journey that adjusts to your needs, keeping you warm or cool as the seasons change.	Stay asleep with individually-wrapped coils which help minimize motion transfer. Cooling graphite and copper gel layer absorbs and transfers heat away from the body.
Support	This mattress is crafted for optimal support using a blend of certified foams. Targeted contouring zones ensure balanced weight distribution across the body. Layers respond swiftly to position shifts, offering buoyant support beyond typical memory foam. Individually-pocketed coils combined with high-density foam provide stability and motion isolation. Every layer is meticulously designed for a supportive sleep, ensuring you wake up refreshed.	Two-sided edge support with Reinforced Quantum Edge - use the whole sleeping surface and easily get in and out of the bed. Energex foam provides pressure relief over a wide range of temperature.
Posts	IN THE CLOUDS A blog for better sleep, happy homes, and healthy lifestyles. [Read more]	–

Size & weight

	Puffy Diamond	Allswell Supreme
Available sizes	Twin XL, Full (Double), Queen, King, California King, Split King	Twin, Twin XL, Full (Double), Queen, King, California King
Dimensions	Twin: 16 "	Twin: 14 "
Twin weight (kg)	–	56
Twin XL weight (kg)	–	59
Full (Double) weight (kg)	–	78
Queen weight (kg)	–	92
King weight (kg)	–	116
California King weight (kg)	–	116

FAQs

Puffy Diamond

What does hybrid mattress mean?

A hybrid mattress merges the supportive features of an innerspring mattress with the softness of memory foam. The Puffy Diamond Hybrid enhances this by integrating pocketed coils with high-quality materials like alpaca wool, premium latex, and multiple layers of refined memory foams.

How often should you change your mattress?

Typically, mattresses last 7-8 years, but luxury ones like Puffy can go up to 10 years. If your mattress is over 5 years old or isn't comfortable, consider getting a new one. Puffy offers a 101-night trial and a lifetime warranty for assured comfort and reliability.

What is the weight capacity of the Puffy mattresses?

Puffy mattresses cater to diverse sleepers and weights. The twin to full-size mattresses support up to 350 lbs. The larger sizes like queen, king, and California king can hold 350 lbs on each side.

Allswell Supreme

How thick is Allswell Supreme?

The Allswell Supreme mattress has a thickness of 14 inches.

What is the weight limit for the Allswell Supreme?

The Allswell Supreme mattress can comfortably support individuals who weigh up to 230 pounds.

How long can I leave an Allswell mattress in a box?

It is recommended not to keep an Allswell mattress in its box for more than 30 days from the date of purchase.

Wrap up

Thank you for checking out this Puffy Diamond vs Allswell Supreme mattress comparison. We have tried to compare all the necessary information to help you choose which mattress is the most suitable for you.

Related comparisons

← All United States comparisons