🇨🇦 Canada · All Foam vs Memory foam
Brooklyn Bedding PlankvsPuffy
Which one is best for you? Brooklyn Bedding Plank vs Puffy - 2026 comparison by Mattress Battles
Vs Mattress is reader-supported, that means if you buy something via a link on this page, we might earn a commission. Thank you kindly.
Pricing by size
Brooklyn Bedding Plank
Puffy
Essential information
| Brooklyn Bedding Plank | Puffy | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | All Foam | Memory foam |
| Launched | 2009 | 2017 |
| Brand | Brooklyn Bedding | Puffy |
| Made in | United States | Canada |
| Unique points | Inspired by the minimalist approach to sleep in the Far East, the Plank is the firmest, flattest, healthiest way to sleep. It has 4 layers of construction:
| Puffy has three layers of construction:
|
| Video | Watch video | – |
Certifications & trial
| Brooklyn Bedding Plank | Puffy | |
|---|---|---|
| OEKO-TEX® | No | Yes |
| CertiPUR-US® | Yes | Yes |
| Certifications | CertiPur-US® | CertiPur-US®, OEKO-TEX® |
| Other certification info | – | – |
| Sleep trial | 120 Nights nights | 101 Nights nights |
| Warranty | 10 Years | LIFETIME |
| Free shipping | – | – |
| Free returns | Yes | Yes |
| Pay later | Yes | No |
| Delivery info | Shipping to Canada is done via UPS. For Canadian orders, it can take 3-5 business days after processing. All taxes and duties are included. Shipping calculated at checkout. | Get the best sleep of your life delivered directly to your door for no extra charge within 1 to 3 business days. |
Firmness & feel
| Brooklyn Bedding Plank | Puffy | |
|---|---|---|
| One firmness fits all | No | Yes |
| Select your firmness | No | No |
| Adjustable firmness | Yes | No |
| Half and half firmness | No | No |
| Flippable / reversible | Yes | No |
| Firmness info | Dual comfort design: Firm top side and ultra-firm bottom side for customizable sleep. Plank Firm mattress offers versatile firmness options. Choose between an ultra-firm or traditional firm sleep experience. | Experience the ideal firmness with our 5-layer sleep system. The Puffy Mattress combines a stain-resistant cloud cover, cooling cloud foam, climate comfort foam, firm core support base, and a grip base cover to deliver optimal cooling, comfort, and support for a restful sleep. |
Construction & materials
| Brooklyn Bedding Plank | Puffy | |
|---|---|---|
| Layers | Quilted Top, TitanFlex™ Foam, High-Density Base Foam, Quilted Bottom. | Cooling Cloud™ Foam. ClimateComfort™ Foam. Firm Core Support Foam. |
| Cover | The flippable design of the Plank allows you to choose your ideal firmness level: a .75" quilted top layer, patterned with continuous stitching, ensures zero loft for an ultra-firm sleep experience - or, flip the mattress, and a 1.5" quilted layer, patterned with tack-and-jump stitching, creates minimal loft for a firm sleep experience. | Your Puffy comes with an all-new Stain Resistant Cover! Quickly and easily wipe up spills while leaving your cover just as white and clean. Our Zip-N-Wash cover allows for seasonal deep cleaning to remove dirt and germs that build up from regular use. Rest assured that you're sleeping on quality - our mattress covers are Oeko-Tex® Standard 100 Certified. |
| Machine-washable cover | No | Yes |
| Ergonomic handles | No | No |
| Comfort | Engineered to reduce pressure on your circulatory system the Plank provides for better blood flow - and better lower back support, compelling you to inhale more oxygen while you snooze. | The ClimateComfort layer was expertly crafted to resist contraction and expansion during temperature fluctuations, which results in the same consistent feeling year-round. It also acts as a temperature neutralizer, keeping you in a stable and relaxing sleep. Puffy's Cooling Cloud draws heat out of the mattress with its Cloud Gel layer to keep your body at an optimal temperature for comfort. Our Puffy mattresses incorporate an advanced temperature-stabilizing, ClimateComfort™ layer that prevents sudden temperature swings that can disrupt a comfortable night's sleep. Expect a subtle warming effect during the cold winter months and a cooling effect during a hot summer. |
| Support | The Plank offers a firmer, flatter, flippable surface for a neutral spine position that's better for your back and posture overall. A 2" layer of our firmest transitional TitanFlex™ foam adds deep compression support. A 7" high density base foam ensures durability and stability for the life of your bed. | The Puffy mattress offers balanced support and contouring, making it perfect for all types of sleepers. Puffy's Cooling Cloud and Firm Core Support foam will adapt perfectly to every point of your body, letting you forget you're even on a mattress. Puffy's Firm Core Support Layer is specially designed to keep your spine aligned while eliminating pressure points. |
| Posts | – | Over 17,100 Reviews Our commitment to helping our customers sleep better to live better has never been stronger. Curious to know why customers think … |
Size & weight
| Brooklyn Bedding Plank | Puffy | |
|---|---|---|
| Available sizes | Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King | Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King |
| Dimensions | Twin: 11 " | Twin: 10 " |
| Twin weight (kg) | N/A | 29 |
| Twin XL weight (kg) | N/A | 30 |
| Full weight (kg) | N/A | 40 |
| Queen weight (kg) | N/A | 48 |
| King weight (kg) | N/A | 61 |
| California King weight (kg) | N/A | 61 |
FAQs
Brooklyn Bedding Plank
Is the plank mattress a bed in box?
Yes, the Plank Firm mattress is a bed-in-a-box that is particularly suitable for back and stomach sleepers due to its supportive nature.
Is the plank mattress good for stomach sleepers?
The firm side of the Plank Mattress provides adequate support for most stomach sleepers' midsections, preventing excessive sinking. It's particularly suitable for stomach sleepers weighing over 130 pounds due to its firmness.
What is the plank mattress made of?
The Plank mattress features an ultra-firm side. It's constructed with proprietary TitanFlex foam, a latex alternative that offers firmness, support, and pressure relief. The core of the Plank Firm is made up of high-density polyfoam.
Puffy
Is Puffy Mattress healthy?
All foams used in Puffy mattresses are CertiPUR-US® certified. Each foam layer is independently tested in a lab to meet the highest global foam safety and quality standards. This ensures that the mattress doesn't contain harmful chemicals.
Is Puffy a memory foam mattress?
Yes, the Puffy is a memory foam mattress. It consists of three layers: a 2-inch layer of gel-infused foam, a 2-inch layer of temperature-regulating foam, and a 6-inch layer of high-density support foam.
What type of mattress is Puffy?
Puffy is an all-foam mattress that provides a soft, cushiony feel. It's ideal for sleepers who enjoy the deep contouring feel of memory foam. The mattress gives sleepers the sensation of being cradled.
Thank you for checking out this Brooklyn Bedding Plank vs Puffy mattress comparison. We have tried to compare all the necessary information to help you choose which mattress is the most suitable for you.
Related comparisons
- Puffy Royal vs Brooklyn Bedding Plank
- Endy Hybrid vs Brooklyn Bedding Plank
- Emma CliMax Hybrid vs Brooklyn Bedding Plank
- Simba Green Organic vs Brooklyn Bedding Plank
- Venus Williams Legend vs Brooklyn Bedding Plank
- Ghost SmartBed vs Brooklyn Bedding Plank
- GhostBed 3D Matrix vs Brooklyn Bedding Plank
- GhostBed Natural vs Brooklyn Bedding Plank
- Puffy Royal vs Puffy
- Endy Hybrid vs Puffy
- Emma CliMax Hybrid vs Puffy
- Simba Green Organic vs Puffy
- Venus Williams Legend vs Puffy
- Ghost SmartBed vs Puffy
- GhostBed 3D Matrix vs Puffy
- GhostBed Natural vs Puffy