🇺🇸 United States · Hybrid (coils and foam) vs Memory foam

Allswell SupremevsPuffy

Which one is best for you? Allswell Supreme vs Puffy - 2026 comparison by Vs Mattress

Vs Mattress is reader-supported, that means if you buy something via a link on this page, we might earn a commission. Thank you kindly.

Allswell SupremePuffyEnjoy $1,350 In Savings

Allswell Supreme

by Allswell · Hybrid (coils and foam)

10 years · 100-night trial

Top pick

Puffy

by Puffy · Memory foam

Enjoy $1,350 In Savings

LIFETIME · 101-night trial

Pricing by size

Allswell Supreme

Twin$517

Twin XL$547

Full (Double)$597

Queen$687

King$797

California King$797

Puffy

Twin$1,449

Twin XL$1,499

Full (Double)$1,649

Queen$1,799

King$1,999

California King$1,999

Essential information

	Allswell Supreme	Puffy
Type	Hybrid (coils and foam)	Memory foam
Launched	–	–
Brand	Allswell	Puffy
Made in	United States	United States
Unique points	The Supreme mattress by Allswell is the best in their lineup, constructed of the following layers: Quilted Cover + Euro Top Graphite & Copper Gel Infused Memory Foam Energex Foam Quantum Edge Individually Wrapped Coils.	The new updated version of Puffy (released February, 2019) now has three layers of construction: 2" Cooling Cloud Foam 2" ClimateComfort Foam 6" Firm Core Support Foam.
Video	–	Puffy Mattress - The Most Comfortable Mattress

Certifications & trial

	Allswell Supreme	Puffy
OEKO-TEX®	No	Yes
CertiPUR-US®	Yes	Yes
Certifications	CertiPur-US®	CertiPur-US®, OEKO-TEX®
Other certification info	<p id="">Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)USDA Organic GREENGUARD Gold Eco-INSTITUT MADE SAFE® Rainforest Alliance Certified™ Forest Stewardship Council®</p>	–
Sleep trial	100 nights	101 nights
Warranty	10 years	LIFETIME
Free shipping	–	–
Free returns	Yes	Yes
Pay later	Yes	Yes
Delivery info	Allswell offers free ground shipping to the 48 contiguous US states & DC.	Get the best sleep of your life delivered in a box straight to your door in 3 - 6 Business Days. Better sleep should be easy and Puffy makes it so.

Firmness & feel

	Allswell Supreme	Puffy
One firmness fits all	Yes	Yes
Select your firmness	No	No
Adjustable firmness	No	No
Half and half firmness	No	No
Flippable / reversible	No	No
Firmness info	That just-right medium-firm feel. Rated a 4.5 to 6.5 on the very unscientific firmness scale.	Puffy is a 6 to 8 on the firmness scale. Offering a Medium-Firm comfort.

Construction & materials

	Allswell Supreme	Puffy
Layers	Quilted Cover + Euro Top, Graphite & Copper Gel Infused Memory Foam, Energex Foam, Quantum Edge Individually Wrapped Coils.	2" Cooling Cloud Foam, 2" ClimateComfort Foam, 6" Firm Core Support Foam.
Cover	Quilted top panel woven with our signature A. This is a Euro top mattress with two layers of high-performance memory foam underneath its plush quilted surface which makes for a supreme sleep experience.	Easily removable/washable zip cover.
Machine-washable cover	No	Yes
Ergonomic handles	No	No
Comfort	Stay asleep with individually-wrapped coils which help minimize motion transfer. Cooling graphite and copper gel layer absorbs and transfers heat away from the body.	What makes Puffy the perfect bed? The secret is consistency. You can expect the same comfortable and supportive sleep year-round - regardless of the environment. Thanks to an additional layer to both Puffy models that is made of our ClimateComfort Foam, this foam provides high pressure-relieving capabilities across a broad range of temperature and humidity levels - making it resistant to the contraction and expansion that often occurs from extreme temperatures (often attributed to seasonal climate change). Specifically, it is designed to prevent contraction in the cold and expansion in the heat. Cooling Cloud Comfort Layer We've got the competition beat! Our patent pending Cooling Cloud Memory foam disperses heat away from your body using convection and conduction allowing for more effective airflow. Puffy's Gel Infused Foam increases airflow 8x more than standard foam mattresses that you can purchase online, leaving you cool, comfortable and well rested.
Support	Two-sided edge support with Reinforced Quantum Edge - use the whole sleeping surface and easily get in and out of the bed. Energex foam provides pressure relief over a wide range of temperature.	The Puffy Mattress is not only comfortable, but it's also strong and durable. Puffy's 6" Firm Support Layer and its Insta-Firm technology provides 99% better responsiveness and four times the support of standard mattresses. In fact, Puffy will be the most supportive mattress you ever sleep on! The base layer is a polyurethane foam (non-latex) manufactured with our VPF. It is a full six inches and provides exceptional support and spinal alignment for restorative sleep.
Posts	–	IN THE CLOUDS A blog for better sleep, happy homes, and healthy lifestyles. [Read more]

Size & weight

	Allswell Supreme	Puffy
Available sizes	Twin, Twin XL, Full (Double), Queen, King, California King	Twin, Twin XL, Full (Double), Queen, King, California King
Dimensions	Twin: 14 "	Twin: 10 "
Twin weight (kg)	56	29
Twin XL weight (kg)	59	30
Full (Double) weight (kg)	78	40
Queen weight (kg)	92	48
King weight (kg)	116	61
California King weight (kg)	116	61

FAQs

Allswell Supreme

How thick is Allswell Supreme?

The Allswell Supreme mattress has a thickness of 14 inches.

What is the weight limit for the Allswell Supreme?

The Allswell Supreme mattress can comfortably support individuals who weigh up to 230 pounds.

How long can I leave an Allswell mattress in a box?

It is recommended not to keep an Allswell mattress in its box for more than 30 days from the date of purchase.

Puffy

Is puffy mattress healthy?

Yes, all Puffy mattress foams are CertiPUR-US® certified. Each foam layer is independently tested in a lab to meet the highest global foam safety and quality standards. It's been thoroughly tested to ensure it doesn't contain harmful chemicals.

How do you clean a Puffy mattress?

The Puffy Cloud Mattress is designed for easy cleaning and maintenance. Its Cloud Cover, which is stain-resistant, features a zip-n-wash design and can be spot cleaned using mild detergents or other gentle household cleaning products. To maintain freshness, the Puffy Signature Mattress Protector, which is waterproof and comes free with any mattress purchase, can be used. It offers comfort akin to a cloud and is made of premium cooling materials.

Does the Puffy Mattress sag?

Like many all-foam beds, it may start to sag earlier than a mattress that includes innerspring support. However, Puffy offers a lifetime warranty on this mattress, so if your old Puffy mattress starts to sag you may be able to replace it for free!

Wrap up

Thank you for checking out this Allswell Supreme vs Puffy mattress comparison. We have tried to compare all the necessary information to help you choose which mattress is the most suitable for you.

Related comparisons

← All United States comparisons